Strictly speaking and oddly enough, the best-selling disposable vape in the United States is not actually legal to sell, and not owing to a unique quirk of one particular state or a bad batch. Elf Bar, and its sister brand Lost Mary, are sold on hundreds of thousands of American counters every day, and the Food and Drug Administration has authorized neither of them.
Both are made by the same Chinese manufacturer, and both are ubiquitous, although these popular, heavily-marketed products are outside of the law, in a strange way that has come to define how America has been regulating vaping, of late.
Last month the FDA sent warning letters to eighty retailers across fifteen states, telling them to stop selling unauthorized Elf Bar and Lost Mary products. Eight shops that had been warned already, and carried on regardless, are now facing civil penalties of $20,678 apiece.
This was not the agency’s first endeavor, in this regard. It has issued more than 690 such letters to date, alongside 140-odd penalty actions, with letters instructing retailers to remove the products within fifteen working days and explain how they will avoid selling them again.
You might say the results of this aggressive campaign speak for themselves, with Elf Bar remaining the number-one disposable vape in the country. You can buy one anywhere that sells vapes.
Thirty-Four Products
The reason so much of the market is illegal is that the legal market is tiny. The FDA has authorized just thirty-four vape products in total. Those are the only e-cigarettes a shop may lawfully sell, and most of them are tobacco or menthol pods made by the big tobacco companies.
Everything else, such as the fruit flavors, disposables, and thousands of products Americans actually buy day-to-day, exists outside that list, which means that a store stocking only authorized vapes would have almost nothing its customers want. Naturally, stores tend to stock products that sell, and so the letters continue to pile up, and the difference between the rule and the shelf grows a little wider each quarter.
If none of this sounds particularly newsworthy, you might want to remember what these products are for. A vape is a way off cigarettes, which ultimately kill around half their long-term users, but the FDA is not pursuing the cigarettes, which remain on sale at every gas station in America. It is pursuing the mint-flavored, arguably safer, alternative to them.
Lost Mary in Britain
Lost Mary is perfectly legal in the United Kingdom. When Britain banned single-use disposables in 2025, the brand did not vanish or go underground, it simply redesigned its hardware into refillable, rechargeable devices that complied with the new rules, and carried on selling openly.
Walk into any British shop, or visit any online store, and the Lost Mary vape is a legitimate, regulated product, with no warning letters involved, because none are needed. Britain set rules a manufacturer could actually meet, and the manufacturer went ahead and met them.
And therein lies the whole difference. The brand is identical on both sides of the Atlantic, but the regulation is completely different. Britain built a legal route to market and watched the industry take it, while America built a route so narrow that its most popular vape could not fit through it, and the industry found another way.
Dear Retailer
The FDA is not wrong that teenagers buy these things, because some do. But enforcement that produces its seven-hundredth warning letter while the targeted product stays number one is not enforcement. It is merely correspondence.
Nothing about the current approach is likely to change the shelves, of course. The best-selling vape in America will still be there next month, unauthorized and seemingly unhindered, while the letters keep arriving and the penalties keep being ignored. It is, one might conclude, a very peculiar way to run a market, and an even stranger way to lose one.
